I've got a CD upgrade opportunity

S

s2000db

Guest
Hi guys, for reasons that I won't go into:?, I've been offered an upgrade of my CDP, the choice around £1k that I've got to choose from is Arcam, Cyrus, Denon. Marantz, MF, and Roksan Caspian.

What are your thoughts please? Thanks

 

Davewhityetagain

Wammer
Wammer
Jul 24, 2005
11,690
4
0
, ,
s2000db wrote:

Hi guys, for reasons that I won't go into:?, I've been offered an upgrade of my CDP, the choice around £1k that I've got to choose from is Arcam, Cyrus, Denon. Marantz, MF, and Roksan Caspian.What are your thoughts please? Thanks
Arcam MF or even Denon would be my short list

 

icehockeyboy

Wammer
Wammer
Aug 14, 2005
4,963
73
93
Torquay Devon. UK
AKA
Craig
HiFi Trade?
  1. No
Is that the only choice? i ask as id steer you towards the cdp i bought, i had the MF X Ray v3, and the A3.2, and they are both good cdp's, but the Eastern wees on them. There was a letter in HFW from a guy who tried MF A3.5 and A5, plus a Meridian, and something else, a Naim or Linnmaybe, and he chose the Eastern, saying it was the closest you can get to the red book thing.

Having said that, if that list is your only option, i would go for MF, as you should be able to get something at a discount price now.

 

Papa Lazarou

Wammer
Wammer
Aug 18, 2005
12,907
147
123
Bletchley, Bucks
AKA
Phil
HiFi Trade?
  1. No
icehockeyboy wrote:

Is that the only choice? i ask as id steer you towards the cdp i bought, i had the MF X Ray v3, and the A3.2, and they are both good cdp's, but the Eastern wees on them. There was a letter in HFW from a guy who tried MF A3.5 and A5, plus a Meridian, and something else, a Naim or Linnmaybe, and he chose the Eastern, saying it was the closest you can get to the red book thing.Having said that, if that list is your only option, i would go for MF, as you should be able to get something at a discount price now.
:gag:re the Minimax.

How about that Audionet V2 in the classifieds section if you can slightly stretch your budget? Superbly built, german engineering and superb performance.

 

technobear

Ursine Wammer
Wammer Plus
Sep 11, 2005
2,687
111
143
Glastonbury, UK
AKA
Chris
HiFi Trade?
  1. Yes
  2. No
s2000db wrote:

Hi guys, for reasons that I won't go into:?, I've been offered an upgrade of my CDP, the choice around £1k that I've got to choose from is Arcam, Cyrus, Denon. Marantz, MF, and Roksan Caspian.What are your thoughts please? Thanks
<shameless plug mode on>

If you're willing to go second hand you can trash all of those with one of these:

http://www.hifiwigwam.com/view_topic.php?id=10132&forum_id=5

<shameless plug mode off>

 

griffo104

Wammer
Wammer
Sep 30, 2005
6,818
1,472
158
Newport
AKA
Griffo
HiFi Trade?
  1. No
From the few times I've heard them I think the Cyrus and MF players are quite close to each other sonically- not the same but have similar characteristics. I'm not a fan of either of them so I wouldn't recommend them.

I quite like Denon, used their DVD2900 as a substitute cd player for a while and could quite happily have lived with it for longer, so I would go for the Denon.

 

ErikFH

Wammer
Wammer
Aug 2, 2005
3,100
5
0
Netherlands
AKA
Erik
HiFi Trade?
  1. No
Edit, cos Biccy forgotmentioning the MF.
wink.png


 

Testure

Clean gloves hide dirty hands
Wammer Plus
Jul 21, 2005
6,118
59
128
West London/ Watford
AKA
Testy
HiFi Trade?
  1. Yes
s2000db wrote:

Hi guys, for reasons that I won't go into:?, I've been offered an upgrade of my CDP, the choice around £1k that I've got to choose from is Arcam, Cyrus, Denon. Marantz, MF, and Roksan Caspian.What are your thoughts please? Thanks
Curious which model of Marantz?

 

harv

Wammer
Wammer Plus
Jan 5, 2006
1,654
100
143
deepest S.London, ,
AKA
erm... guess
technobear wrote:

s2000db wrote:
Hi guys, for reasons that I won't go into:?, I've been offered an upgrade of my CDP, the choice around £1k that I've got to choose from is Arcam, Cyrus, Denon. Marantz, MF, and Roksan Caspian.What are your thoughts please? Thanks
<shameless plug mode on>

If you're willing to go second hand you can trash all of those with one of these:

http://www.hifiwigwam.com/view_topic.php?id=10132&forum_id=5

<shameless plug mode off>
The audionet really is a cracking spinner, having just bought one a couple of weeks ago for a little more then one in the classifieds:(... I also have a Classe CDP 10 which is very good too... very different to the Audionet much warmer and softer sounding with better texture. Both are excellent... but I've got to choose one and sell the other and I'm going to keep the V2... depending on your partnering equipment and personal taste... you might prefer the Classe but either of the players wouldn't disappoint... Also seen a Wadia 830 for that money too...

 
S

s2000db

Guest
Unfortunately, I have to stick with the brands listed, as my dealer is currently being very accomodating with me...

Looks like the Marantz will have to be deleted as they don't stock any thing between £429 and £1999.

So that narrows it down a bit - any views on the MF X-rayv8 vs the A3.5?

Cheers DB

 

Boxer

Wammer
Wammer
Nov 2, 2005
9,074
15
0
Out of those I'd say Arcam or MF.

Personally do NOT rate Caspian electronics: harsh & grainy (a cliched "transistor" sound if ever there was one) & not at all pleasant; boogies along well enough, but so do the Arcam FMJ & the X-Ray...

Shame no Naim or Rega or Expo...

Boxer

 
U

Umberto

Guest
Cyrus CD8x is a nice player, albeit a little lean soundingand lacking in prescence. I have also heard the Marantz SA-11 which was quite bright sounding and the Arcam CD93 which was quite smooth sounding.

 

alex

Wammer
Wammer
Oct 6, 2005
45
0
21
, ,
the caspian m series should not be overlooked it is imho a smooth and detailed player but one mans meat etc. listen to all players on your list if you can, then ask for a home demo of maybe two of players you have shortlisted.alex.

 

icehockeyboy

Wammer
Wammer
Aug 14, 2005
4,963
73
93
Torquay Devon. UK
AKA
Craig
HiFi Trade?
  1. No
s2000db wrote:

Unfortunately, I have to stick with the brands listed, as my dealer is currently being very accomodating with me...Looks like the Marantz will have to be deleted as they don't stock any thing between £429 and £1999.

So that narrows it down a bit - any views on the MF X-rayv8 vs the A3.5?

Cheers DB
The X ray v3 is an A3.2 basically, in a smaller box, i was told this by an employee at MF, despite what others might say, folk say the 3.5 is a better player than its earlier model............ i prefer the larger cased stuff...........

 

ErikFH

Wammer
Wammer
Aug 2, 2005
3,100
5
0
Netherlands
AKA
Erik
HiFi Trade?
  1. No
icehockeyboy wrote:

The X ray v3 is an A3.2 basically, in a smaller box, i was told this by an employee at MF, despite what others might say, folk say the 3.5 is a better player than its earlier model............ i prefer the larger cased stuff...........
To my(and HFN)ears the X-ray V3wasan improvement over the 3.2. I think theyhaddifferent dacs but could be wrong.

Btw, question was V8 vs 3.5. MFreleases (to) many models in the same price range.

 

gsrai

Wammer
Wammer
Aug 18, 2005
5,991
87
0
Black Country
AKA
Gobind
s2000db wrote:

Unfortunately, I have to stick with the brands listed, as my dealer is currently being very accomodating with me...Looks like the Marantz will have to be deleted as they don't stock any thing between £429 and £1999.

So that narrows it down a bit - any views on the MF X-rayv8 vs the A3.5?

Cheers DB
DB

I've just done a reviewette on the new MF X-Series in the equipment review section.

I think the X-Ray V8 is fantastic but do bear in mind that the player is £800 and you need a XXX PSU which is a further £300 to make it work!

I wouldn't bother with the A3.5 as they tend to go for £5-600 on eBay and that's new!

I had the Cyrus CD8x and I would go with the MF X-ray V8 (if you go for the X-T100 amp then the XXX PSU comes with it for £900 so you then only buy the CD player).

Either way, Cyrus or MF, there are upgrades a plenty to keep you tweaking for the whole of eternity!

Are you sure you cant get the Marantz SA15 ( I think that's really nice and is definetly under £2k)

 
E

earl of sodbury

Guest
Curiously, given what I've owned in the past, and what I've said about the brand - I would definitely not discount the Roksan Kaspian: Build can be iffy, but the very latest iteration is actually very good and a more interesting listen than most of the rest...

...the exception being the MF X-rayV8 - but I suspect that on its own it will be good, but unremarkable - I think Gobind's advice to secure the amp as well would ultimately be the direction to take were it me.

Arcam's always underrated - it's highly neutral, and if you like long listening sessions to challenging music, then this should be very high inyour list.

I've only ever heard one Cyrus system that sounded any good, and the owner of that sold it all and bought some goldy-lookin' japcrap
wink.png


Not heard current Denon kit, but Davewhit seems to have been impressed with his, and he's owned a LOT of kit...

good luck, churz, eofs

 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,298
Messages
2,317,219
Members
69,450
Latest member
RichShortland